breakingthe lines

Linear, Logarithmic and Percent Price Scales Tested on HirschmannPrivate by a Retired Hydrologist

This HirschmannPrivate review has a retired hydrologist testing linear, logarithmic and percent price scales, plus ranges and order lines on long charts.

6 Nov 20265 min

Hydrologists read gauge records for years before they trust a single line. A river that rises two feet from a low base and a river that rises two feet from a high base tell different stories, and the plotting scale decides whether the page shows that difference or hides it. After a career spent on those plots, I assumed a price chart would be a simpler cousin. It was not, and the reason had little to do with the market.

I retired with spare time and a modest sum, and I wanted to know whether the chart axis on HirschmannPrivate would let me read a long move the way I once read a long flood record. For several weeks I kept a notebook of every scale setting I changed and what the picture did afterward. This HirschmannPrivate review is built from that notebook, and its subject is the price scale and what it makes a chart appear to say.

Where a Gauge Record Taught Me to Doubt an Axis

On a river chart the vertical axis can be linear or logarithmic, and the choice is printed in the corner of the page. Nobody who reads those plots forgets to check it. A price chart offers the same choice, yet the setting sits in a menu and the default is easy to accept without a glance. My first task was to find where the platform states its scale and how plainly it does so.

The scale control lives inside the chart settings, and the axis itself shows price levels along the right edge. I wrote down the default on my first day, then opened a long daily history of one instrument I already follow. The early years looked flat and the recent years looked dramatic, though the early moves had been large in proportion to the price at that time.

What the Linear Scale Hides on a Long Chart

A linear axis gives every dollar of price the same height. That suits a short window, where a one dollar move means about the same thing at the start and at the end. Over several years it breaks down, because a dollar on a low price is a large proportional move and a dollar on a high price is a small one. On the long chart I tested, a rise that looked modest near the left edge had been a bigger percentage move than a taller rise near the right edge.

I checked this with the crosshair readout. The crosshair gave the price at each point, and I divided the difference by the starting price on paper. The arithmetic confirmed what my eye had misjudged. That is a point about scales in general and not a complaint about the platform, and it is why I treat a linear long view as a rough sketch and not a measurement.

Switching Scales for This HirschmannPrivate Review 

Changing the scale on HirschmannPrivate took one settings change, and the chart redrew with the studies I had attached still in place. On the logarithmic setting, equal vertical distances represent equal percentage moves, so the early years regained their shape. The axis labels became unevenly spaced, which is correct but unfamiliar. I had to read the numbers instead of assuming the gaps were regular.

A percent mode, where the axis shows change from a chosen starting bar, answered a slightly different question. It was handy for asking how far a move had traveled from the point where I began watching. It was less handy for judging absolute price levels, so I switched back and forth depending on the question. Any HirschmannPrivate review of charting has to treat those as separate questions.

Two things I checked deliberately. The first was whether an indicator drawn beneath the chart changed when the scale changed. It did not, which is right, because an indicator is computed from prices and not from the picture. The second was whether a horizontal level I had drawn stayed at the same price. It did, including after I reloaded the page.

Manual Ranges, Auto Fit and the Last Bar

The vertical range was the next setting I tested. With auto fit on, the axis stretches to hold whatever bars are visible. Scrolling back in time therefore changed the scale under me, and a quiet stretch looked as lively as a violent one because the axis had zoomed to fit it. Gauge plots avoid this by fixing the range across comparison panels, and I wanted the same discipline here. Locking the range kept two stretches of history directly comparable.

The cost is that the latest bars can run off the edge of a locked range. One afternoon the price moved beyond my fixed limits and the current bar sat outside the visible area. I noticed only because the price label on the axis showed a number I did not expect. A manual range needs a glance at that label every time, and I added it to my routine.

Orders Drawn on the Chart Stay Tied to Price

The worry any scale change raises is whether lines for orders and stops follow the picture or the number. Following the picture would be dangerous. I placed a pending order on the ticket, then switched between linear, logarithmic and percent views and watched the line. It moved on the screen as the axis stretched, yet its price label never changed, and the orders list showed the same level throughout. The line was a drawing of the order, and the number matched in both places every time I looked.

Distance to a stop reads differently on each scale. On a linear axis, a stop two dollars below the price looks the same size anywhere on the chart. On a logarithmic axis, the same two dollars looks smaller when the price is high. I stopped judging stop distance by eye and wrote the number from the ticket beside my sketch. Working from the printed figures removed the disagreement between scales.

Scale Habits a Gauge Reader Carries Over to Price Charts

Four habits survived the weeks of testing. Find the scale type in the settings before judging any move on the chart. For anything longer than a few months, look at the logarithmic or percent view next to the linear one. Lock the range when comparing two stretches of history, then unlock it when watching live prices. Measure stop distances from the numbers on the ticket, not from the picture.

The notebook held axis settings and little else, so this review leaves markets aside. The scale options say nothing about whether an instrument is worth trading, and a tidy axis cannot supply a reason for an order.

Seen through a gauge reader's habits, this HirschmannPrivate review ends on a plain result. The scale controls were quick to reach, they behaved consistently with the drawing tools and the order list, and the axis could be inspected and changed in seconds.

Any platform can show a long move only as honestly as its axis allows. Here the axis is open to checking, which is what a gauge reader asks of a chart before believing it.

Users can learn more about the platform by visiting HirschmannPrivate.com. 

Disclaimer: The content of this article is provided for general informational purposes only and should not be interpreted as personalized financial or trading advice. The author makes no representations or warranties regarding the accuracy, completeness, or timeliness of the information presented. Market dynamics are subject to frequent change, and past insights may not reflect current conditions. Readers should independently verify all facts and consult with a qualified financial advisor before making any investment decisions. The author and publisher accept no responsibility for any financial losses, decisions, or consequences resulting from reliance on this content. All actions taken based on this information are at your own risk.

BT
0subscribers